Quiet Gouache Glass

npx shadcn@latest add button card input textarea select dialog sheet tabs badge separator checkbox switch slider tooltip dropdown-menu table

:root {
  --background: #F8F9FB;
  --foreground: #18222B;
  --card: #FFFFFF;
  --card-foreground: #18222B;
  --popover: #FFFFFF;
  --popover-foreground: #18222B;
  --primary: #24313B;
  --primary-foreground: #ffffff;
  --secondary: #E7EBF0;
  --secondary-foreground: #111111;
  --muted: #65717D;
  --muted-foreground: #18222B;
  --accent: #D96F5F;
  --accent-foreground: #ffffff;
  --destructive: #B84B43;
  --border: #DDE3EA;
  --input: #DDE3EA;
  --ring: #D96F5F;
  --chart-1: #24313B;
  --chart-2: #E7EBF0;
  --chart-3: #D96F5F;
  --chart-4: #6F9B72;
  --chart-5: #C79543;
  --sidebar: #FFFFFF;
  --sidebar-foreground: #18222B;
  --sidebar-primary: #24313B;
  --sidebar-primary-foreground: #ffffff;
  --sidebar-accent: #5F8EA8;
  --sidebar-accent-foreground: #ffffff;
  --sidebar-border: #DDE3EA;
  --sidebar-ring: #D96F5F;
  --radius: 18px;
}

.dark {
  --background: #0f1115;
  --foreground: #f8fafc;
  --card: #181b22;
  --card-foreground: #f8fafc;
  --popover: #181b22;
  --popover-foreground: #f8fafc;
  --primary: #24313B;
  --primary-foreground: #ffffff;
  --secondary: #252a33;
  --secondary-foreground: #f8fafc;
  --muted: #252a33;
  --muted-foreground: #a1a1aa;
  --accent: #D96F5F;
  --accent-foreground: #ffffff;
  --destructive: #B84B43;
  --border: #303642;
  --input: #303642;
  --ring: #D96F5F;
  --chart-1: #24313B;
  --chart-2: #E7EBF0;
  --chart-3: #D96F5F;
  --chart-4: #6F9B72;
  --chart-5: #C79543;
  --sidebar: #181b22;
  --sidebar-foreground: #f8fafc;
  --sidebar-primary: #24313B;
  --sidebar-primary-foreground: #ffffff;
  --sidebar-accent: #D96F5F;
  --sidebar-accent-foreground: #ffffff;
  --sidebar-border: #303642;
  --sidebar-ring: #D96F5F;
  --radius: 18px;
}

import { Badge } from "@/components/ui/badge";
import { Button } from "@/components/ui/button";
import {
  Card,
  CardContent,
  CardDescription,
  CardFooter,
  CardHeader,
  CardTitle,
} from "@/components/ui/card";
import { Input } from "@/components/ui/input";
import { Tabs, TabsList, TabsTrigger } from "@/components/ui/tabs";

export function QuietGouacheGlassShadcnKit() {
  return (
    <section className="grid gap-4 rounded-[var(--radius)] border bg-background p-4 text-foreground">
      <div className="flex items-start justify-between gap-4">
        <div>
          <Badge variant="outline">shadcn/ui</Badge>
          <h2 className="mt-3 text-2xl font-semibold tracking-tight">Quiet Gouache Glass</h2>
          <p className="mt-1 max-w-xl text-sm text-muted-foreground">
            Use the Katagami registry theme, then compose these shadcn primitives
            with the language-specific component recipes.
          </p>
        </div>
        <Button>Apply theme</Button>
      </div>

      <Tabs defaultValue="components">
        <TabsList>
          <TabsTrigger value="components">Components</TabsTrigger>
          <TabsTrigger value="states">States</TabsTrigger>
          <TabsTrigger value="export">Export</TabsTrigger>
        </TabsList>
      </Tabs>

      <Card>
        <CardHeader>
          <CardTitle>Component recipe</CardTitle>
          <CardDescription>
            Replace this starter content with the agent-authored product scene
            from components.md and preview-shots.json.
          </CardDescription>
        </CardHeader>
        <CardContent className="grid gap-3 sm:grid-cols-[1fr_auto]">
          <Input defaultValue="Tokenized shadcn surface" aria-label="Recipe name" />
          <Button variant="secondary">Preview state</Button>
        </CardContent>
        <CardFooter className="justify-between">
          <Badge>Ready</Badge>
          <Button variant="outline">Copy recipe</Button>
        </CardFooter>
      </Card>
    </section>
  );
}

{
  "$schema": "https://ui.shadcn.com/schema/registry-item.json",
  "cssVars": {
    "dark": {
      "accent": "#D96F5F",
      "accent-foreground": "#ffffff",
      "background": "#0f1115",
      "border": "#303642",
      "card": "#181b22",
      "card-foreground": "#f8fafc",
      "chart-1": "#24313B",
      "chart-2": "#E7EBF0",
      "chart-3": "#D96F5F",
      "chart-4": "#6F9B72",
      "chart-5": "#C79543",
      "destructive": "#B84B43",
      "foreground": "#f8fafc",
      "input": "#303642",
      "muted": "#252a33",
      "muted-foreground": "#a1a1aa",
      "popover": "#181b22",
      "popover-foreground": "#f8fafc",
      "primary": "#24313B",
      "primary-foreground": "#ffffff",
      "radius": "18px",
      "ring": "#D96F5F",
      "secondary": "#252a33",
      "secondary-foreground": "#f8fafc",
      "sidebar": "#181b22",
      "sidebar-accent": "#D96F5F",
      "sidebar-accent-foreground": "#ffffff",
      "sidebar-border": "#303642",
      "sidebar-foreground": "#f8fafc",
      "sidebar-primary": "#24313B",
      "sidebar-primary-foreground": "#ffffff",
      "sidebar-ring": "#D96F5F"
    },
    "light": {
      "accent": "#D96F5F",
      "accent-foreground": "#ffffff",
      "background": "#F8F9FB",
      "border": "#DDE3EA",
      "card": "#FFFFFF",
      "card-foreground": "#18222B",
      "chart-1": "#24313B",
      "chart-2": "#E7EBF0",
      "chart-3": "#D96F5F",
      "chart-4": "#6F9B72",
      "chart-5": "#C79543",
      "destructive": "#B84B43",
      "foreground": "#18222B",
      "input": "#DDE3EA",
      "muted": "#65717D",
      "muted-foreground": "#18222B",
      "popover": "#FFFFFF",
      "popover-foreground": "#18222B",
      "primary": "#24313B",
      "primary-foreground": "#ffffff",
      "radius": "18px",
      "ring": "#D96F5F",
      "secondary": "#E7EBF0",
      "secondary-foreground": "#111111",
      "sidebar": "#FFFFFF",
      "sidebar-accent": "#5F8EA8",
      "sidebar-accent-foreground": "#ffffff",
      "sidebar-border": "#DDE3EA",
      "sidebar-foreground": "#18222B",
      "sidebar-primary": "#24313B",
      "sidebar-primary-foreground": "#ffffff",
      "sidebar-ring": "#D96F5F"
    },
    "theme": {}
  },
  "meta": {
    "componentManifest": [
      "button",
      "card",
      "input",
      "textarea",
      "select",
      "dialog",
      "sheet",
      "tabs",
      "badge",
      "separator",
      "checkbox",
      "switch",
      "slider",
      "tooltip",
      "dropdown-menu",
      "table"
    ],
    "installCommand": "npx shadcn@latest add button card input textarea select dialog sheet tabs badge separator checkbox switch slider tooltip dropdown-menu table",
    "languageId": "en-019e467f-0c85-7e13-a75e-8312444576e3",
    "nativeTokenNames": {
      "borders": [
        "accent_width",
        "character",
        "default_width",
        "style"
      ],
      "colors": [
        "accent",
        "background",
        "border",
        "error",
        "info",
        "muted",
        "primary",
        "secondary",
        "success",
        "surface",
        "text",
        "warning"
      ],
      "motion": [
        "duration",
        "easing",
        "philosophy"
      ],
      "radii": [
        "full",
        "lg",
        "md",
        "none",
        "sm"
      ],
      "shadows": [
        "lg",
        "md",
        "sm"
      ],
      "spacing": [
        "base",
        "scale"
      ],
      "surfaces": [
        "bg_pattern",
        "card_style",
        "treatment"
      ],
      "typography": [
        "base_size",
        "body_font",
        "google_fonts_url",
        "heading_font",
        "letter_spacing",
        "line_height",
        "mono_font",
        "scale_ratio"
      ]
    },
    "slug": "quiet-gouache-glass",
    "source": "katagami"
  },
  "name": "quiet-gouache-glass",
  "title": "Quiet Gouache Glass shadcn Theme",
  "type": "registry:theme"
}

# Quiet Gouache Glass shadcn/ui Components

Artifact: `component-recipes-v1`
Author: `katagami-ui-projection`
Language ID: `en-019e467f-0c85-7e13-a75e-8312444576e3`
Slug: `quiet-gouache-glass`

## Intent

An evolved child of Gouache System Glass that keeps Apple-clean frosted product minimalism and memorable paint intelligence, but removes all colored side rails, stripes, accent borders, and template-dashboard decoration in favor of quieter semantic color surfaces, icons, chips, and content-backed fields.

## Required primitives

- button
- card
- input
- textarea
- select
- dialog
- sheet
- tabs
- badge
- separator
- checkbox
- switch
- slider
- tooltip
- dropdown-menu
- table

Install with `npx shadcn@latest add button card input textarea select dialog sheet tabs badge separator checkbox switch slider tooltip dropdown-menu table`.

## Token cues

Colors:

{
  "accent": "#D96F5F",
  "background": "#F8F9FB",
  "border": "#DDE3EA",
  "error": "#B84B43",
  "info": "#5F8EA8",
  "muted": "#65717D",
  "primary": "#24313B",
  "secondary": "#E7EBF0",
  "success": "#6F9B72",
  "surface": "#FFFFFF",
  "text": "#18222B",
  "warning": "#C79543"
}

Typography:

{
  "base_size": "16px",
  "body_font": "Source Sans 3",
  "google_fonts_url": "https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=Geist:wght@500;600;700&family=IBM+Plex+Mono:wght@400;500;600&family=Source+Sans+3:wght@400;500;600;700&display=swap",
  "heading_font": "Geist",
  "letter_spacing": "-0.018em",
  "line_height": 1.5,
  "mono_font": "IBM Plex Mono",
  "scale_ratio": 1.22
}

## Visual character to preserve

- Use cool neutral glass panes with backdrop-filter blur, white-to-silver linear gradients, inset frost hairlines, and large rounded-rect geometry committed to one 18px family.
- Integrate gouache color as filled micro-surfaces, selected chips, icon-backed status dots, data marks, and one meaningful content panel rather than any one-sided border or stripe.
- Keep the page background clean and almost blank with soft radial light pools only, avoiding square grids, dotted notebook motifs, and decorative texture as default identity.
- Build hierarchy through spacious Apple-like typography, unboxed group alignment, subtle dividers, and a single offset workspace composition break instead of stacks of cards.
- Use a reduced color-theory set of muted coral, mineral blue, and moss green with warm amber reserved for warnings, applied through semantic foreground marks and filled states.

## ShadSync visual profile

{
  "family": "system",
  "material": "flat",
  "contour": "default",
  "border": "solid",
  "underlay": true,
  "grain": true,
  "stickerBadges": false,
  "motion": "lift",
  "density": "balanced",
  "accents": [
    "primary",
    "accent",
    "secondary",
    "muted"
  ]
}

## Signature component recipes

### Button
Use `Button` for primary, secondary, outline, and ghost actions. Primary actions must expose the language's strongest contrast pair, while secondary and ghost actions should preserve the surface treatment instead of falling back to default neutral SaaS styling.

### Card
Use `Card`, `CardHeader`, `CardContent`, `CardFooter`, and `CardAction` as the main composition frame. Cards should demonstrate the language's surface, border, hierarchy, and density rules rather than appearing as generic rounded rectangles.

### Input and Textarea
Use `Input` and `Textarea` with visible focus rings, field labels, validation states, and the language's rhythm. Forms should show real product content, not placeholder-only controls.

### Select, Tabs, and Table
Use `Select`, `Tabs`, and `Table` to prove navigation, filtering, and dense data states. The table should show row rhythm, separators, hover/focus states, and an empty or status state when the language calls for it.

### Dialog and Sheet
Use `Dialog` for centered decisions and `Sheet` for contextual editing. Both should inherit the language's spacing, border, overlay, and motion rules.

## Preview shots

- `application-shell`: dashboard or workspace shell with navigation, cards, forms, and state badges.
- `detail-editor`: focused editing flow using input, textarea, select, switch/checkbox, dialog or sheet, and action buttons.
- `data-operations`: table-heavy operational view with tabs, dropdown menu affordances, badges, and destructive/empty states.
- Each preview shot must include a renderable `scene` payload with concrete headline, description, actions, and rows/fields/stats for the UI preview.

## Implementation contract

- Start from local `ui/src/components/ui` shadcn-style primitives; do not create a second component system.
- Apply `/katagami/shadcn/quiet-gouache-glass/registry-theme.json` variables, then use these recipes for composition and state design.
- Preserve Katagami token names as source metadata; shadcn semantic names are only the export surface.
- Do: Use color only as filled chips, selected states, icons, data marks, foreground swatches, or one meaningful content-backed panel.; Keep glass surfaces neutral with consistent 18px radius geometry and inset frost hairlines.; Let product copy, material states, and review workflows create scene specificity.; Use muted coral, mineral blue, moss green, and rare amber with clear semantic ownership.
- Do not: Do not use colored side rails, left borders, side stripes, line markers, or accent borders on cards, buttons, rows, panels, or list items.; Do not use square-grid backgrounds, default dotted notebook texture, rainbow sprays, or hue-wheel palette demonstrations.; Do not present a generic analytics dashboard, CRM board, or component catalog as the main embodiment.; Do not add nested cards, arbitrary glow, gradient text, or decorative accents that fail a removal test.

## Copy-paste component example

This generated starter proves the import shape. Production Katagami agents should replace it with a language-specific product composition.

```tsx
import { Badge } from "@/components/ui/badge";
import { Button } from "@/components/ui/button";
import {
  Card,
  CardContent,
  CardDescription,
  CardFooter,
  CardHeader,
  CardTitle,
} from "@/components/ui/card";
import { Input } from "@/components/ui/input";
import { Tabs, TabsList, TabsTrigger } from "@/components/ui/tabs";

export function QuietGouacheGlassShadcnKit() {
  return (
    <section className="grid gap-4 rounded-[var(--radius)] border bg-background p-4 text-foreground">
      <div className="flex items-start justify-between gap-4">
        <div>
          <Badge variant="outline">shadcn/ui</Badge>
          <h2 className="mt-3 text-2xl font-semibold tracking-tight">Quiet Gouache Glass</h2>
          <p className="mt-1 max-w-xl text-sm text-muted-foreground">
            Use the Katagami registry theme, then compose these shadcn primitives
            with the language-specific component recipes.
          </p>
        </div>
        <Button>Apply theme</Button>
      </div>

      <Tabs defaultValue="components">
        <TabsList>
          <TabsTrigger value="components">Components</TabsTrigger>
          <TabsTrigger value="states">States</TabsTrigger>
          <TabsTrigger value="export">Export</TabsTrigger>
        </TabsList>
      </Tabs>

      <Card>
        <CardHeader>
          <CardTitle>Component recipe</CardTitle>
          <CardDescription>
            Replace this starter content with the agent-authored product scene
            from components.md and preview-shots.json.
          </CardDescription>
        </CardHeader>
        <CardContent className="grid gap-3 sm:grid-cols-[1fr_auto]">
          <Input defaultValue="Tokenized shadcn surface" aria-label="Recipe name" />
          <Button variant="secondary">Preview state</Button>
        </CardContent>
        <CardFooter className="justify-between">
          <Badge>Ready</Badge>
          <Button variant="outline">Copy recipe</Button>
        </CardFooter>
      </Card>
    </section>
  );
}
```

## Layout notes

{
  "breakpoints": "mobile 375px, tablet 768px, desktop 1440px with navigation becoming top segmented tabs below 820px",
  "grid": "Twelve-column desktop grid with a 260px calm navigation column, fluid glass workbench, and offset inspector; collapses to two columns on tablet and one column on mobile.",
  "whitespace": "Large outer gutters and precise 16-24px internal gaps create calm; unframed spacing is preferred over wrapping every unit in a card."
}

{
  "artifact": "katagami:shadcn-preview-shots",
  "version": "preview-shots-v1",
  "generator": "katagami-ui-compatibility-projection",
  "generatedBy": "katagami-ui-projection",
  "requiresVisualProfile": true,
  "schema": "katagami:shadcn-preview-shots/renderable-v1",
  "renderable": true,
  "language": {
    "id": "en-019e467f-0c85-7e13-a75e-8312444576e3",
    "name": "Quiet Gouache Glass",
    "slug": "quiet-gouache-glass"
  },
  "installCommand": "npx shadcn@latest add button card input textarea select dialog sheet tabs badge separator checkbox switch slider tooltip dropdown-menu table",
  "primitives": [
    "button",
    "card",
    "input",
    "textarea",
    "select",
    "dialog",
    "sheet",
    "tabs",
    "badge",
    "separator",
    "checkbox",
    "switch",
    "slider",
    "tooltip",
    "dropdown-menu",
    "table"
  ],
  "identityNotes": [
    "Use cool neutral glass panes with backdrop-filter blur, white-to-silver linear gradients, inset frost hairlines, and large rounded-rect geometry committed to one 18px family.",
    "Integrate gouache color as filled micro-surfaces, selected chips, icon-backed status dots, data marks, and one meaningful content panel rather than any one-sided border or stripe.",
    "Keep the page background clean and almost blank with soft radial light pools only, avoiding square grids, dotted notebook motifs, and decorative texture as default identity.",
    "Build hierarchy through spacious Apple-like typography, unboxed group alignment, subtle dividers, and a single offset workspace composition break instead of stacks of cards.",
    "Use a reduced color-theory set of muted coral, mineral blue, and moss green with warm amber reserved for warnings, applied through semantic foreground marks and filled states."
  ],
  "visualProfile": {
    "family": "system",
    "material": "flat",
    "contour": "default",
    "border": "solid",
    "underlay": true,
    "grain": true,
    "stickerBadges": false,
    "motion": "still",
    "density": "balanced",
    "accents": [
      "primary",
      "accent",
      "secondary",
      "muted"
    ]
  },
  "shots": [
    {
      "id": "application-shell",
      "title": "Application shell",
      "viewport": "desktop",
      "primitives": [
        "button",
        "card",
        "input",
        "select",
        "tabs",
        "badge",
        "separator",
        "table"
      ],
      "composition": "A real product workspace with navigation, summary cards, filtering controls, and one dense content region.",
      "mustShow": [
        "primary and secondary actions",
        "card hierarchy",
        "filterable state",
        "table or list density"
      ],
      "avoid": [
        "component inventory walls",
        "placeholder-only content",
        "generic rounded SaaS chrome"
      ],
      "scene": {
        "eyebrow": "workspace spread",
        "headline": "Quiet Gouache Glass launch room",
        "description": "A product team workspace where navigation, filters, metrics, and dense rows carry the language's visible structure.",
        "primaryAction": "Apply theme",
        "secondaryAction": "Review states",
        "stats": [
          {
            "label": "components",
            "value": "16",
            "tone": "accent"
          },
          {
            "label": "states",
            "value": "ready"
          },
          {
            "label": "density",
            "value": "balanced",
            "tone": "warning"
          }
        ],
        "rows": [
          {
            "label": "Primary flow",
            "value": "mapped",
            "status": "active"
          },
          {
            "label": "Token coverage",
            "value": "semantic",
            "status": "synced"
          },
          {
            "label": "Responsive proof",
            "value": "queued",
            "status": "review"
          }
        ],
        "statuses": [
          "Active",
          "Synced",
          "Draft"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "detail-editor",
      "title": "Detail editor",
      "viewport": "tablet",
      "primitives": [
        "button",
        "card",
        "input",
        "textarea",
        "select",
        "checkbox",
        "switch",
        "slider",
        "dialog",
        "sheet"
      ],
      "composition": "A focused editing flow with form fields, validation, confirmation, and a contextual side panel.",
      "mustShow": [
        "focus ring",
        "error or destructive state",
        "dialog or sheet treatment",
        "written guidance content"
      ],
      "avoid": [
        "unstyled browser controls",
        "floating cards inside cards",
        "missing labels"
      ],
      "scene": {
        "eyebrow": "editing flow",
        "headline": "Language recipe editor",
        "description": "A focused form proving labels, validation, toggles, panel rhythm, and action hierarchy.",
        "primaryAction": "Save recipe",
        "secondaryAction": "Open sheet",
        "fields": [
          {
            "label": "Component family",
            "value": "Narrative cards"
          },
          {
            "label": "State treatment",
            "value": "Visible focus + validation"
          },
          {
            "label": "Motion",
            "value": "Small lift, no opacity-only fade"
          }
        ],
        "statuses": [
          "Focus",
          "Invalid",
          "Confirmed"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "data-operations",
      "title": "Data operations",
      "viewport": "mobile",
      "primitives": [
        "button",
        "tabs",
        "badge",
        "dropdown-menu",
        "table",
        "tooltip",
        "separator"
      ],
      "composition": "A compact operational view proving row rhythm, stacked actions, menu states, badges, and empty/destructive states.",
      "mustShow": [
        "responsive reflow",
        "dense row styling",
        "menu affordance",
        "status badge system"
      ],
      "avoid": [
        "desktop-only tables",
        "text overflow",
        "default shadcn spacing without Katagami character"
      ],
      "scene": {
        "eyebrow": "operations",
        "headline": "Compact review queue",
        "description": "A narrow viewport scene with rows, menus, tooltips, badges, and destructive affordances.",
        "primaryAction": "Resolve",
        "secondaryAction": "Filter",
        "rows": [
          {
            "label": "Button hierarchy",
            "value": "approved",
            "status": "ok"
          },
          {
            "label": "Table rhythm",
            "value": "needs pass",
            "status": "watch"
          },
          {
            "label": "Empty state",
            "value": "designed",
            "status": "done"
          }
        ],
        "statuses": [
          "Queued",
          "Blocked",
          "Done"
        ]
      }
    }
  ],
  "componentRecipes": [
    {
      "primitive": "button",
      "intent": "Prove action hierarchy, focus, disabled, and destructive states."
    },
    {
      "primitive": "card",
      "intent": "Carry the language surface, border, elevation, and density rules."
    },
    {
      "primitive": "input",
      "intent": "Show labels, focus rings, validation, and spacing rhythm."
    },
    {
      "primitive": "textarea",
      "intent": "Show longer guidance, validation copy, and writing density."
    },
    {
      "primitive": "select",
      "intent": "Show filtering, selection contrast, and menu trigger styling."
    },
    {
      "primitive": "dialog",
      "intent": "Show centered decision states and overlay treatment."
    },
    {
      "primitive": "sheet",
      "intent": "Show contextual side panels and responsive editing."
    },
    {
      "primitive": "tabs",
      "intent": "Show navigational structure and active/inactive contrast."
    },
    {
      "primitive": "badge",
      "intent": "Show compact status vocabulary and semantic colors."
    },
    {
      "primitive": "separator",
      "intent": "Show section rhythm without generic gray dividers."
    },
    {
      "primitive": "checkbox",
      "intent": "Show binary selection with visible focus and checked states."
    },
    {
      "primitive": "switch",
      "intent": "Show settings toggles and on/off contrast."
    },
    {
      "primitive": "slider",
      "intent": "Show numeric adjustment with track/thumb styling."
    },
    {
      "primitive": "tooltip",
      "intent": "Show concise explanation styling above compact controls."
    },
    {
      "primitive": "dropdown-menu",
      "intent": "Show action menus, destructive items, and grouped choices."
    },
    {
      "primitive": "table",
      "intent": "Show dense operational data, separators, row states, and responsive behavior."
    }
  ],
  "qualityRules": {
    "do": [
      "Use color only as filled chips, selected states, icons, data marks, foreground swatches, or one meaningful content-backed panel.",
      "Keep glass surfaces neutral with consistent 18px radius geometry and inset frost hairlines.",
      "Let product copy, material states, and review workflows create scene specificity.",
      "Use muted coral, mineral blue, moss green, and rare amber with clear semantic ownership."
    ],
    "dont": [
      "Do not use colored side rails, left borders, side stripes, line markers, or accent borders on cards, buttons, rows, panels, or list items.",
      "Do not use square-grid backgrounds, default dotted notebook texture, rainbow sprays, or hue-wheel palette demonstrations.",
      "Do not present a generic analytics dashboard, CRM board, or component catalog as the main embodiment.",
      "Do not add nested cards, arbitrary glow, gradient text, or decorative accents that fail a removal test."
    ]
  }
}